Heuristic Evaluation for Better UX

Eliminate usability problems early by having your website evaluated using heuristic analysis. Discover why this method is so valuable.

31.01.2025 1 min reading time
Written by: Stephanie Wölke Lead UX Design

Contents

  1. In a nutshell
  2. Why is it so popular with UX and UI?
  3. 10 usability heuristics according to Nielsen
  4. Vor- und Nachteile
  5. Implementation in 3 steps
  6. Heuristic evaluation of websites

In a nutshell: Heuristic Evaluation

  • Method for identifying usability problems
  • Goal: Improve user-friendliness
  • Usability heuristics published by Jakob Nielsen in 1994
  • Cost-efficient, fast, and effective
  • Characterized by subjectivity – experienced evaluators are necessary
  • Particularly useful for websites and digital applications

Why UX and UI love Heuristic Evaluation

Heuristic evaluation in UX is the best method for checking the user-friendliness of websites or apps quickly and easily. It is based on predefined heuristics or rules.

During the heuristic analysis, we check whether a website complies with these heuristics or identify where it falls short. Passed? Great. If not, add it to the revision list. There’s one small caveat:

In order for this method to deliver complete and, above all, useful results, the heuristic evaluation must be conducted by experienced evaluators.

“Heuristics are only as effective as the expertise of the UX professional who carries out the evaluation.“

— Rolf Molich, award-winning expert in CPUX certification and heuristic evaluation

H2 Advantages of Heuristic Analysis at a Glance

Our interaction design teams particularly favor this method because of its three main advantages:

  • 01

    Identifies usability problems

    Using heuristics, we uncover numerous usability issues at once.

  • 02

    Few people, strong results

    Only a small team of evaluators is needed to obtain well-founded results.

  • 03

    Strong in early phases

    Heuristic analysis makes all the difference, especially in the early phases of product development.

How user-friendly is your website?

Our UX experts perform a heuristic analysis and show you screen by screen.

What is a Heuristic?

We use heuristics daily – little rules of thumb that simplify decisions, especially when time, information, or motivation is limited.

In broader terms, heuristics are experience-based methods that help solve problems quickly and pragmatically without testing every possible solution.

The 10 heuristics by Nielsen (1994), modernly interpreted in ISO standard ISO 9241-110.

The 10 Usability Heuristics according to Nielsen

Jakob Nielsen, a Danish pioneer in usability, introduced 10 core usability heuristics in 1994. Even over 30 years later, these principles remain widely used and highly relevant for evaluating user-friendliness.

10 Heuristics

1. Visibility of the system status

The system should always give users feedback and keep them informed of its current status.

Example: Loading bars or status messages that indicate task progress.

2. Match between the system and the real world

The website or digital application should use language and terms familiar to users.

Example: Common icons, like a trash can for deleting items, and familiar terminology.

3. User control and freedom

Users should feel in control of the system and have easy ways to correct mistakes or exit unwanted situations.

Example: Undo functions or clearly accessible navigation options.

4. Consistency and standards

The system should be consistent and follow industry standards.

Example: Consistent fonts, colors, and navigation placement through a design system.

5. Error prevention

The website or app should contain security precautions to avoid unintentional errors by users.

Example: Confirmation messages for critical actions, like deleting important data.

6. Recognition rather than recall

The system should minimize memory load by displaying options, actions, and objects visibly.

Example: Drop-down menus that list all available options.

7. Flexibility and efficiency

The system should work for both beginners and advanced users.

Example: Keyboard shortcuts for experienced users and simple menus for beginners.

8. Aesthetics and minimalist design

The design should be simple and uncluttered, avoiding unnecessary elements that compete for attention.

Example: Avoid overly busy pages with excessive information or graphics.

9. Help with errors

Errors should be clearly identified, and the system should provide constructive solutions.

Example: Clear error messages explaining what went wrong and how to fix it.

10. Help and documentation

The system should offer easily accessible assistance and documentation.

Example: Online help pages or context-sensitive support that provides guidance exactly where it’s needed.

Advantages and Disadvantages of Heuristic Evaluation

Advantages

  • Cost-efficient: Requires only a few evaluators.
  • Fast: Quick to execute and delivers results rapidly.
  • Effective: Identifies many usability issues that can be addressed right away.
  • Early-stage benefits: Detects and resolves issues early in development, helping to avoid costly changes later.

Disadvantages

  • Subjectivity: Results rely on the individual expertise of evaluators, making experience critical.
  • Not comprehensive: Heuristic evaluation doesn’t address all usability problems. It should be combined with other testing methods for more thorough results.
  • Limited number of heuristics: Evaluators only assess the system against a small set of heuristics, which may not fully capture usability complexities.
  • Potential blind spots: According to Nielsen, this method can miss issues that fall outside the applied heuristics.

The heuristics have been around since 1994, which is why a modern interpretation is necessary. One particularly relevant standard is ISO 9241-110, which provides comprehensive guidance for conducting a modern heuristic evaluation. Additional examples of guidelines can be found in the Guidelines for Human-AI Interaction by Saleema Amershi et al., which outline 18 practical recommendations with examples of both applications and violations.

Heuristic Evaluation: 3 Steps to Good Results

Our experience for your project

Boost the usability of your website or app long before it’s finalized.

How our UX and UI Teams Heuristically Evaluates Websites

Our experienced experts step into the role of users, closely analyzing:

  • Pages and functions relevant to the business
  • Interface elements, Emotional Design, and content
  • The complete customer journey
The analysis shows how users navigate between pages and evaluates the design of individual UI elements.

When evaluating websites, we at Moccu focus on the following areas:

  • Navigation and structure: Clear, logical, and easy-to-navigate layouts
  • Emotional Design, content, and readability: Well-structured, easy-to-understand, and visually appealing designs (starting with a UX audit)
  • Interactive elements: Intuitive and user-friendly functionality
  • Visual design: Aesthetic appeal paired with functional design
  • Mobile optimization: Seamless performance across devices and screen sizes
  • Search functionality: Efficient, user-friendly search features
  • Accessibility: Inclusive designs that adhere to accessibility standards
  • Loading times and performance: Fast load times for improved user satisfaction and conversions
  • Security aspects: Reliable handling of sensitive data to foster user trust
The structured evaluation process delivers clear results, including direct action recommendations, applied heuristics, and a screenshot highlighting key details.

Frequently Asked Questions

Would you like to know more? Then get in touch.

Thomas Walter Managing Director & Partner

Your message has been sent

Thank you for your message! We will get in touch with you as quickly as possible!

Our expert

Stephanie Wölke Lead UX Design

Since December 2015, Stephanie Wölke has been the UX Design Lead at Moccu. She expertly leads UX design projects, focusing on creating user-centred, usable, and inclusive digital solutions that deliver outstanding results. With her expertise and ♥️ for testing, she formulates innovative UX strategies that significantly enhance UX and strengthen clients' brand identities and goals.

LinkedIn

All articles by Stephanie Wölke

More articles on usability and design

Back to Insights Back to Top